Both Chartered Accountancy (CA) and Company Secretaryship (CS) are two different and professional courses in the commerce field. This article aims to differentiate between the two, thereby helping Class 12 commerce students. But let us first know what CA and CS are.
Chartered Accountancy (CA) gives professionals expertise in accounting, auditing, taxation, financial management, and corporate finance. They are regulated by professional bodies like the Institute of Chartered Accountants of India (ICAI). On the other hand, a Company Secretary (CS) specialises in corporate law, governance, and regulatory compliance and is regulated by the Institute of Company Secretaries of India (ICSI). As various experts put it, both CA and CS are two complementary facets of business management-financial expertise and legal governance.
CA versus CS: Know the difference?
A Chartered Accountant (CA) mainly works with accounting, auditing, management accounting, taxes, and giving financial advice. A Company Secretary (CS), on the other hand, focuses on corporate laws, helps with important company decisions, and plans strategies.
Nowadays, a CA’s job is changing from just handling accounts and audits to also advising business leaders on how to increase profits in a responsible way that cares for the environment and society. Meanwhile, a CS advises the company’s top management on legal matters and makes sure the company follows all the rules. The CS acts like the company’s internal legal expert.
CA versus CS: Know similarities?
Both CA and CS courses have some things in common. For example, CS students learn about accounting and keeping records, while CA students study some company law. Because of this, doing both CA and CS together can be very helpful and can make a person’s career very successful.
Some people start their career as a Company Secretary and later also become a Chartered Accountant. The CA profession is managed by the Institute of Chartered Accountants of India (ICAI), and the CS profession is managed by the Institute of Company Secretaries of India (ICSI).
Story continues below this ad
CA versus CS: How to choose?
Both CA and CS are good courses for commerce students, but choosing one depends on what a student likes. If a student is interested in auditing, accounting, and taxes, then CA is a better choice. If they like law and how it works in companies, then CS is the right path.
CA takes about five years to complete and is more difficult, while CS takes around three years and is easier to finish. However, the career options for CS are a bit limited. A Company Secretary acts as an important link between the company, its board of directors, shareholders, government, and other authorities. They work in different areas like management, taxes, finance, and international trade.
The role of a Chartered Accountant is also changing. With new technology like artificial intelligence, machine learning, and blockchain, CA studies are becoming more tech-focused. This technology helps in areas like auditing, taxes, and legal work. There are many job opportunities for CAs in data analysis and cybersecurity.
Similarly, with new technology, Company Secretaries also handle things like software copyrights, licenses, and cyber law compliance.
Story continues below this ad
CA versus CS: How to choose? Career prospects
Because Chartered Accountants (CAs) can work in many different areas, they usually have more job opportunities. On average, CAs also earn more money than Company Secretaries (CS). CAs have more power and can even represent their clients in some legal cases, like a lawyer, which CS cannot do.
However, there are still many job opportunities for Company Secretaries. Any company with a paid-up share capital of Rs 2 crore or more must have a Company Secretary to help run the company smoothly.
—Kachwala is chairman, Western India Regional Council of the Institute of Chartered Accountants of India (WIRC of ICAI)
